To protect client safety, we are offering the ability to meet with us via telephone, email or through video conferencing. Contact our office to discuss your options.

justice delivered


Medicare Set Asides Not Required in Personal Injury Cases, Holds NJ Court

A 2012 case from the Federal District Court of New Jersey is instructive for Medicare-eligible California residents who are considering a settlement in a personal injury case in 2019.

To begin, however, let’s first define what a Medicare Set Aside (MSA) is according to MSA’s are often related to Workers Compensation settlements but relates to personal injury settlements as well. It states on the Medicare and Medicaid Services website a Medicare Set Aside: “is a financial agreement that allocates a portion of a workers’ compensation settlement to pay for future medical services related to the workers’ compensation injury, illness, or disease. These funds must be depleted before Medicare will pay for treatment related to the workers’ compensation injury, illness, or disease.” (Source, last updated January 2019) 

The New Jersey case arose after a truck driver, who worked for Trans Am Trucking, crashed into a bus in March 2006. Sipler was a passenger on the bus and sued Trans Am Trucking.

Shortly before the scheduled trial date, the parties verbally agreed to settle the case, with the trucking company agreeing to pay Sipler $225,000. In return, Sipler agreed to release the company from any other potential claims from the 2006 collision.

Thereafter, the attorneys representing the trucking company sent a proposed release of claims to Sipler. Although no other terms had been agreed upon in the earlier settlement discussion, the release included additional provisions, including:

  • A confidentiality clause
  • A clause prohibiting Sipler from claiming “reimbursement from Medicare for injuries arising” from the accident
  • A statement indicating “Medicare will not pay for any future treatment for injuries arising out of the accident”

Consequently, Sipler refused to sign the release and filed a motion with the court to enforce the original settlement agreement.

In this particular case, Sipler was eligible for Medicare, but none of his medical expenses had been paid by Medicare, as they were covered by an auto insurance policy and a group health insurance plan.

Therefore, the court considered whether, under the Medicare Secondary Payer statute, the settlement agreement was required to contain provisions indicating he would not seek payments from Medicare and that he would set aside part of the settlement to use “for future medical expenses arising out of the accident,” referred to as a Medicare set aside.

The Medicare Secondary Payer statute provides that when a Medicare-eligible individual has private insurance that has paid or will pay for specific medical expenses, Medicare will not contribute to those expenses.

The court noted that Medicare set-aside agreements were not mandated by federal law in personal injury settlements. Such agreements are common in workers’ compensation settlements; however, the court observed the circumstances of a personal injury settlement are distinguishable. Payments in workers’ compensation cases are frequently capped by a statutory maximum, whereas personal injury cases can include noneconomic damages and “are not determined by an established formula.”

As a result, the court reasoned, “to require personal injury settlements to specifically apportion future medical expenses would prove burdensome to the settlement process and, in turn, discourage personal injury settlements.”

The court held, “the parties in this case need not include language in the settlement documents noting Mr. Sipler’s obligations to Medicare or fashion a Medicare set-aside for future medical expenses.” In other words, Sipler was not required to agree to the Medicare provisions added to the settlement by the trucking company. The court enforced the settlement as originally agreed upon by the parties.

Source: Sipler v. Trans Am Trucking, Inc., et al, No.10-3550(DRD)(DN.J. July 24, 2012 DeBevoise, S.J.)

Our firm handles situations similar to the one described in this post. If you would like to learn more about our practice, please visit our Los Angeles truck accident page.


FindLaw Network

"5+ Stars for this attorney! There is no better in my book. Thank you for being a great attorney and being there for me when I needed someone on my side. This is the attorney to hire!"

"Scott Corwin exceeded my expectations. He walked me through the entire process but didn't waste my time. He was professional, aggressive, communicative, and efficient. If you want the best, you've found him."

"Scott was diligent, professional, compassionate, honest, and responsive. Scott was able to get me 10 times more than I thought I would receive for my accident. I couldn't recommend a better personal injury lawyer."

"Mr. Corwin is truly an amazing professional with outstanding tenacity and incredible skill for the law. If you want an Attorney that will work and breathe your case, day and night, then Mr. Corwin is the right man."

"I was told that Scott's the best, and he didn't let me down. From the first meeting all the way down through settlement I felt like my interests were being represented by someone knowledgeable, skilled, and that genuinely cared about my outcome."

"The settlement Scott obtained for me has provided my family with the security we need for the future. I recommend Scott Corwin to anyone injured in an accident, whether it's a small case or a life altering injury. He will fight to get you what you deserve."

"The "Force" is with this man! I'm grateful for Mr. Corwin's professionalism and highly recommend him to anyone in need of hi-caliber legal representation."

"Fast, easy, reliable, friendly, and hardworking! Fastest results I've ever heard of. I have only praises to sing about Scott! Will definitely be sending all my friends his way!"

"I got into an accident and I thank god I found Scott Corwin right away. I was treated with respect and all my questions or concerns were always readily answered. He is a rare gem and I highly recommend him."

"I appreciate you for the respectful manner in which you interact with your clients. My experience with you was exactly what I think an attorney client relationship should be. Your keen sensibilities set you apart. You are the consummate professional."

"I'd recommend Scott to anyone and call upon his services again with no hesitation. He's truly a "super lawyer" -- do not wait another minute - you have found your man. Retain him, follow his instructions, and move on with your life. He'll handle everything - what a relief!"

"I located Scott due to stellar reviews that I found online. He exceeded my expectations and I could not be happier with my settlement."

"I was very lucky to come across Scott J. Corwin. Scott made sure I got all the medical treatment I needed. I have worked with many attorneys in the past but Scott is by far the most knowledgeable, responsible, and detail-oriented. I highly recommend him."

"You did a tremendous job! I was extremely surprised and happy with my settlement amount. It was higher than I expected! You definitely are the Super Lawyer!"

"If you need a personal injury attorney who listens, cares about you, is candid, thorough, reassuring, who will be your legal advocate to protect your rights, and will do all he can to obtain the best possible settlement for you, then Scott J. Corwin is that lawyer."

"I have worked with many attorneys in the past but Scott is by far the most knowledgeable, responsible, and detail-oriented attorney I have worked with. I highly recommend him."

"Thank you for your professionalism. You maximized the result for your client and did so much faster than 99% of lawyers ever could or would."

"I am not sure dealing with the aftermath of an accident can ever be hassle-free, but using Scott as your lawyer is about as close as you'll ever get. I give him my most enthusiastic recommendation."

"I enormously appreciate all of the help and hard work you've done for me and for taking care of my doctor's bills."

"Scott was kind, caring and compassionate as well as being an aggressive attorney who was not afraid to take on the insurance company for us. He dealt with everything so I didn't have to deal with anything. I give Scott my highest recommendation."

Hear what our clients have to say

Free Consultations

No Recovery, No fee